MLAS Logo

Discover Our Expert Community

Mr Paul Sutton

Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon MBChB, FRCS(Ed), FRCS(eng), FRCS(Tr &Orth)
Claimants and DefendantsCriminal CasesHome AppointmentsFace to Face AppointmentsCourt AttendanceDesktop Reports16+ Patients

Medico-Legal Experience

Mr Sutton has carried out medico-legal work for over 20 years, providing thorough and detailed reports on a range of cases covering knee conditions and surgery. His current medico-legal practice is exclusively limited to providing expert reports for claims specific to conditions or injuries of the knee.

Mr Sutton has prepared reports under instruction for both Claimant and Defendant cases. He has experience giving expert evidence for medico-legal cases including Coroner’s requests, GMC tribunals and Criminal cases. Mr Sutton can opine on condition and prognosis, breach of duty, liability and causation.

He is renowned for his expertise in all types of knee surgery, including sports injuries as well as joint and cartilage replacement, also specialising in surgery for anterior cruciate ligament injuries and cartilage repair.

Mr Sutton has experience in:

Clinical negligence cases relating to:

  • Lower limb (speciality area – knee)
  • Knee replacement (partial and total)
  • Joint and cartilage replacement/repair
  • Latrogenic cartilage damage
  • Gait analysis
  • Posterior cruciate ligament rupture
  • Osteoarthritis of the knee
  • Chondral injury and surgery
  • Lower limb trauma
  • Sports injuries to lower limb
  • Anterior cruciate ligament injuries
  • Knee arthroscopy (keyhole surgery)
  • Patella stabilisation surgery
  • Surgery for the arthritic knee
  • Tibia fractures
  • Femur fractures
  • Post-operative complications (infections/stiffness)
  • Patellar dislocations
  • Meniscal repair surgery
  • Open reduction internal fixation (ORIF)
  • Soft tissue knee conditions
  • ACL reconstruction
  • Chronic knee pain
  • Autologous chondrocyte implantation surgery
  • Knee bursitis
  • Knee dislocation
  • Knee instability
  • Lower limb exertional compartment syndrome
  • Open reduction internal fixation
  • Patello-femoral joint replacement surgery
  • Tibial osteotomy
  • Trochleoplasty
  • Delayed referral to orthopaedics
  • Inadequate consent before surgery
  • Poor surgical technique:
    – Malpositioned implants
    – Wrong-site surgery
    – Retained foreign body

Mr Sutton’s report turnaround time is 4 – 6 weeks.

Clinical Experience

Mr Sutton was appointed to Sheffield Teaching Hospitals as a Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon with a special interest in knee surgery in May 2001. Working in such a large Teaching Hospital department allows a high degree of specialisation and his work is now exclusively limited to conditions and injuries of the knee. This includes a significant volume of complex knee surgery and ‘second opinion’ referral work.

Mr Sutton also performs Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation Surgery (ACI). This surgery can only be performed in a few specially licenced hospitals within the UK. He has published many scientific papers and book chapters related to knee injuries and their treatment.

Within his NHS practice he treats adult patients of all ages, and athletes of all abilities. In private practice he treats a similar patient group, including elite athletes; gaining extensive experience treating premiership footballers, rugby players and Olympic athletes.

Over the course of his career, he has been involved in many research projects and scientific publications both as lead investigator and as supervisor for surgical trainees. He has published numerous articles relevant to general Orthopaedics and knee surgery in peer review journals and much of this research has been presented at National and International meetings. He is also a shareholder and founder member of Sheffield Orthopaedics Ltd.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Mr Sutton comment on RTA?

Yes, if within remit. Mr Sutton will need more information.

Publications

  • Sutton PM, Howell FR. The protective effect of a cut resistant glove liner: A Randomised Prospective Trial. Podium presentation at the British Orthopaedic Association Annual Congress. Cardiff International Arena. September 1997.
  • Sutton Paul, Livesey Jonathon, Speed Kevin, Bagga Taj. A double-blind prospective randomised controlled trial of oral iron versus placebo for treatment of anaemia after hip and knee replacement. Podium presentation at the New Zealand Orthopaedic Association Annual Scientific Meeting. Waitangi, New Zealand. October 2000.
  • P Sutton B Tietjens , N Stewart. Radial Cleavage tears of the lateral meniscus and a diagnostic radiographic abnormality. Podium presentation at the New Zealand and Australian Orthopaedic Associations Scientific Meeting. Queenstown. October 2001.
  • Paul Sutton Total Knee Replacement: Issues on the Horizon. Invited lecture. Industry session. British Orthopaedic Association Annual Congress. Liverpool 2008.
  • Paul Sutton, Simon Mills, Shaun Rogers, Zain Abiddin, Charalambous P Charalambous, Richard Parkinson. The Low Contact Stress Patellofemoral Arthroplasty – High Early Failure Rate. Podium presentation. International Society of Arthroscopy, knee Surgery & Orthopaedic Sports Medicine (ISAKOS) 8th Biennial Congress Rio De Janeiro. 2011.

Request a Redacted Report

To gain access to a redacted report from this expert, please leave your details below and a member of the team will issue this to you.

Instruct This Expert

To instruct this expert, please leave your details below and a member of the team will be in touch to discuss your requirements.

Venues

Thornbury Hospital

Sheffield, S10 3BR

Spire Claremont Hospital

Sheffield, S10 5UB

Copyright 2025 MLAS - All Rights Reserved.
Terms & Conditions - Sitemap - Modern Slavery Statement